Written
by: Eric Gerson
Princess Mononoke
Producer: Miramax
Suggested Retail Price: $ 32.99
Order
from Amazon.com : $ 26.00
Running Time: 134 Minutes
Rating: B-
Story
Princess Mononoke, Mononoke Hime in Japanese,
is the story of a Prince named Ashitaka and his
journey to lift a curse put upon him by a former
Boar God turned demon. Finding that the Boar God
was changed due to an iron bullet, Ashitaka is
forced to leave his village and journey to the
west to seek those who forged the bullet. Upon
finding the Iron Works, Ashitaka learns of the war
between man and nature over the woods of the Deer
God, whom the humans want to kill. Leading the
fight against the humans is the lovely wolf
princess Mononoke whom Ashitaka falls in love
with. This love is what forces Ashitaka to get
involved in the fight and attempt to stop both
sides from fighting a war that will cause nothing
but pain no matter who wins.
Packaging
Nice cover showing the iron works in the
background with Ashitaka guarding against a sword
attack. The swords have been made holographic for
reasons that may possibly be just for effect. The
top contains basic propaganda of how good the
movie is based off of critic's opinions. Below the
title we are given the names of the main
character's Voice Actors, all of which are well-known and
talented actors. The back cover contains more
propaganda and a basic summary of the story with
screen captures. You are also given a short list of
the extras and features of the audio/video
contained on the disc. Nothing too special or
unique about the packaging, but nothing wrong or
inadequate either. Within the DVD casing we are
given a slip with the cover on the front without
the holographic swords and on the back is the
chapter list with the same screen caps that
appeared on the back casing of the DVD.
Menu
Disappointing in that Miramax is the
company that dubbed and created the DVD. Nothing
but screen captures are used on each page with no
music to accompany them. Navigation is simple
enough but could have been more breathtaking had
just a little more time been put into the layout.
Even the early DBZ DVDs had a better menu than
this, and that is saying a lot.
English
With expected changes from the original version,
the English dub was still excellent. With great
voice actors such as Claire Danes and Billy Bob
Thornton, the character's personalities remained
just as perfect as in the Japanese version. The
problems I had with the English version did not
lie in the actors but rather in the writers.
Changes in dialogue appeared in almost every
sentence, however for the most part the changes
did not ruin the mood or idea of the sentences. No
names were changed with the exception of the
"Deer God" being changed to "Spirit
of the Forest." Furthermore, the word
"God" wasn't used as often as possible,
which doesn't work in an anime about the Gods and
their fight with the human race. The main
character's name "Ashitaka" was given a
different pronunciation that could perhaps be the
translation of the romanizational spelling of
Ashitaka. If you are confused with what I am
talking about, the English version pronounces it
as "ash tee tah kah" while the Japanese
version pronounces it as "a sh taw kaw."
Hopefully you understand now. Anyway, going back
to the voice actors, though the main characters
were given professional actors to voice the roles,
the minor characters, whomever they may have been
voiced by, were well done. No voice was
unnecessarily changed to sound corny or different
from how a normal person speaks. The original
musical score is left in with the exception of one
song that was re-mastered with English dialogue.
In all, the English version had very few problems
and was well done.
Japanese
Just as stated in previous reviews, nothing is
better than the original. Of course there were
production problems in that the subtitles were
yellow, but given a black border. White is a much
better color for subs though; they are easier to
read in all scenes regardless of the amount of
light or dark. If purchasing this DVD I'd suggest
watching the Japanese version before the French or
English just so you can see the perfection of the
story before seeing other versions.
Video
The video for this feature is absolutely
amazing. A did see a few scratches here and there,
but the brilliance and brightness of the colors
makes up for this. I did not however see even one
rainbow appear. In all, the quality of the video
is a huge step up from anime DVDs of the past.
Extras
Once again Miramax disappoints us by giving
us a shady amount of extras of low quality. Only
two appear on this DVD, a featurette (of which I
never can sit through no matter what the movie)
and the theatrical trailer. I was expecting much
more when I chose the bonus material option.
French
To be honest, I didn't watch this version nor do I
ever plan to. I know very little of the neither
French language nor am I used to French dialogue.
I cannot see this version being any less well done
than the English or Japanese versions were. If you
know French and enjoy French films, I'm sure you
will like this section of the DVD.
Final Thoughts
Combining breathtaking art with an amazing story
and given great voice actors, Princess Mononoke is
a treat for anyone who chooses to watch. However,
I did find myself having the stop the movie
halfway through and do something else before being
able to sit down and finish it. Though the plot
itself is very good, the story moves slowly at
times causing the viewer to bore easily.
Furthermore, the ending was in a way
disappointing, you are left with a feeling of
regret that something more exciting did not
happen. Mononoke is a great anime that I suggest
buying, but you're not missing much if you never
see it.
© Eric.
|