Written
by: Eric Gerson
Samurai X: Betrayal
Producer: ADV Films
Suggested Retail Price: $ 29.98
Order
from Amazon.com : $ 25.00
Running Time: 60 Minutes
Rating: A
Story
Second part to "Samurai X: Trust",
"Betrayal" finishes the story of Kenshin
Himura and why he came to be a wanderer. This part
of the movie also reveals the origin of Kenshin's
cross-shaped scar.
Not as violent as "Trust",
"Betrayal" focuses more on Kenshin and
Tomoe's relationship when they leave Kyoto for
Otsu. The story is also much more symbolic; using
red dragon flies and white plums to express
emotions and conflicts between the two characters.
Packaging
Just as "Trust's" packaging was amazing,
so is "Betrayal's". The cover shows
Kenshin standing back-to-back with Tomoe with
their cottage in Otsu behind them. The same
"Samurai X" logo appears and above that
is one of the enemies Kenshin faces at the end.
The back is the same layout as "Trust",
though an explanation of who Kenshin and Tomoe are
appears at the top followed by a summary of the
story for this DVD and ends with a special
features listing and production information. A
screen cap of Tatsumi and Kenshin fighting is cut
to fit the back casing and lies below the summary.
Included within the casing is a slip with the same
cover artwork on the front but with Rurouni
Kenshin again in kanji and romanji. The back of
this slip contains a listing of the trailers along
with the episode titles and chapter listings.
Below the information are images of the various
main characters of "Betrayal". The DVD
itself is the same as with "Trust",
silver with an "X" marked through and
"Samurai X: Betrayal" on one side and
"Rurouni Kenshin: Betrayal" on the
other. The cover is reversible and easy to do.
Just open the casing as much as you can and slide
the cover out. The other cover is absolutely
perfectly created with Rurouni Kenshin written in
both Kanji and Romanji with a picture of Kenshin
holding Tomoe and below that image is a small
image of Kenshin carrying her away. Behind the
title is also Kenshin's swords. A silhouette of
Kenshin's eyes covers the middle part of the DVD
cover. The back is the same on both covers.
Menus
Screenshots are again present but different as
they are shots from the two episodes contained on
this DVD. After selecting where you want to go on
the menu, a slashing sword goes across the screen
before you move to the section you have chosen.
The same music plays as in "Trust" and
continues on each page of the DVD except for the
production notes.
English
The script is again re-written almost completely
changing the mood of the story. The characters are
fine in performance though do not fit with the
character's persona. Rebecca Davis (Tomoe) gives a
performance that leaves you feeling as though she
had no emotion whatsoever toward anyone, including
Kiyosato. Her voicing of Tomoe could have been
better if she expressed more sadness and lowered
her voice from time to time. The original Japanese
music is present, I have to give them that.
However, because of the script changes and voices
that treat the characters as less dramatic than
they should be, the English version of
"Betrayal" is below acceptable.
Japanese
As with "Trust", the same pros and cons
appear on the Japanese version. The story flows
perfectly and the voices and script are absolutely
amazing. Junko Iwao (Tomoe) pulls off the
expression of sorrow for her first love's death
and her growing love for Kenshin magnificently.
Episode 3 takes a different approach to the
previous two as the setting takes place during the
day, symbolizing the change in lifestyle of
Kenshin. He is no longer killing and finds
happiness living with Tomoe and working his
fields; growing his own food. In episode 4, the
setting is between day and night as Kenshin is
broken within from the betrayal of Tomoe.
The subtitles were yellow with no border and again
appeared where there was no dialogue. I had
assumed various possibilities in my
"Trust" review on why this occurred, but
I have to go with production mishaps in that I can
clearly understand some of the dialogue and the
subtitles that appear are not what the characters
said nor ever said in the first place.
Furthermore, the subtitles are incorrect in some
instances and the word "Battousai" and
the "sama", "san", etc.
suffixes are left out.
Extras
Three extras are included on the DVD. The first is
the trailer for the movie once again, followed by
character introductions for the new main
characters in "Betrayal." Finally, the
screenwriter includes his opinions on the story in
"Screenwriter notes." The trailer is
very well done as are the character intros, which
include a summary of the character and a clip of
who they are. The screenwriter's notes however
were incredibly boring to read and absolutely
uninformative.
Final Thoughts
If you liked "Trust" you will love
"Betrayal." After all the action and
seriousness of "Trust," you are given
relief in episode 3 of "Betrayal" as you
are shown the simple life of Kenshin and Tomoe's
faux marriage which later turns into true love. In
order to keep you from forgetting who Kenshin was
and still is, episode 4 returns to the
"Trust" setting in that Kenshin battles
to protect Tomoe and discover who he is within and
what life he will choose to lead. Combining the
drama of Kenshin's relationship with Tomoe and the
fighting that he must endure to defeat the
Shogunate and help in the Meiji Revolution,
"Samurai X: Betrayal" is a DVD that you
will enjoy greatly. Later minna!
© Eric.
|