A 5/5 creature with flying and vigilance for six
mana is an excellent deal. A control deck is
bound to look at this for a finisher at some
point. The persist ability is just gravy, but it
might occasionally be useful if you have to cast
Wrath of God when it's already out -
unfortunately, that does happen sometimes.
Constructed: 3/5
Casual: 3/5
Limited: 4/5
PsychoAnime
#1
Magic Noob in Canada since 2002
Twilight Shepherd
If this card wins the game, it's not because of
its secondary ability. No, it's due to the fact
that it's a persistent and vigilant 5/5 flier.
The persist is pretty good on something so
large, but Oona just does more for 6 mana, and
If you can 3WWW, you can probably make room for
casting Oona instead.
It's really good in limited though.
Constructed: 3/5
Casual: 2/5
Limited: 3.8/5
v0rac10u5
Twilight Shepherd
This card has great potential to generate
card advantage, but Kithkin doesn’t need this
card and the triple white rules out most other
decks.
In limited, this card is a bomb. The 5/5
and 4/4 fliers are worth the cost alone, not
even counting the recurring.
Constructed: 2
Casual: 4
Limited: 5
Miguel
Thursday 6-12-08
Twilight Shepherd
Constructed:
The three white in its casting cost keeps for
high level of play. It a little more expensive
Serra, but with a nice ability. Somebody Wraths
and she goes back to play and you refill your
hand. Us it with yesterday's card Turn to Mist,
fun tricks.
Casual:
Everybody likes angels.
Limited:
A 5/5 flyer with vigilance is just awesome. And
she comes back from the graveyard too! Draft I
would pick it first for white and if it was the
last pack and not my colors I would hate draft
her. Do not what to face out with her.
