|
Scott
Gerhardt
|
Planar
Guide -
Constructed:
3
Limited: 3
Current Price:
$2.95 |
|
Chris
Gerhardt |
Hmm.... This could be
anti-Tog and anti-Wrath. But I can see these
decks jumping through their arse to keep or get
this guy out of play. Its advantage is that
it costs only 1 to make the board, so you may be
able to sneak him in under blue's nose. Black will
probably just Smother or Edict it.
In limited, it could
be used to protect a key creature later in the
game. It's not poorly costed. I'd consider it for
play if I were going white.
Constructed: 3
Limited: 3 |
|
Judge
Bill
|
Planar Guide
THIS is our white 1
drop for the set?!?? His ability will typically
mean absolutely nothing, and so there are many
mroe better cards for the slot. I'll pass.
In limited, however,
... erm, never mind. It's symmetrical, so it
sucks.
Constructed: 1
Limited: 1
|
|
Jason
Chapman |
Planar Guide has some
real possibilities in decks that can be designed
around him (using him for morph is just the most
mundane example). It also provides a good answer
to all the mass removal that decks are packing
these days and that can be some good for WW.
Constructed – A
stellar pick for WW and some rogue decks as well –
4.85
Limited – Also a
standout card here – he can morph and stall out a
game where you are behind – 4.85 |
IQ |
Planar Guide
This guy's hard not to like, he's your average 1/1
for one and comes with a
great effect. I think he has potential in a white
green deck with mana
acceleration and could be pretty nasty in the
right deck. Then again with
all the removal in the environment it'll be hard
to build a deck around him
but one never knows.
In limited he's pretty cool, he'll allow you to
pull crazy morph tricks and
if for some reasin your opponent is playing and
manages to get Phage in play
you win. = p Not like that'll ever happen but it's
still funny enough to
mention.
Constructed 1.5
Limited 2.5 |
|
Scott Sager |
Planar Guide
He's a 1/1 for W with
an added bonus of killing all tokens and creature
enchantment on the board for 3w. It should be a
very useful sideboard card (if not main) for White
decks as long as Roar of the Worm and Call of the
Herd are in the environment.
Limited: It's a 1/1
for 1cc that might pull off a trick or two.
Nothing spectacular.
Constructed: 3
Limited: 2.5 |
|
Danny Tatro |
Planar Guide
I think this guy is a little over-looked. I
wanna make a fun deck with this guy. Maybe play
alot of cool morph creatures, then use this guy to
put them all face up for free. I dunno though...
hes not that good realisticly.
In limited hes pretty bad, but he does give
you fog. and auto morphs for everyone. Still hes
too random really. Plus white in draft isn't good
let alont a 1/1 in limited since its all about the
2/2 and plus power & toughness.
Constructed: 1.5
Limited: 1.5 |
|
Brett
Livingston |
Planar Guide
Astral Slide every creature! Weee!!! He can be a
fog,
or a decent "comes into play" loopy thing, I like
the
picture, but I don't think he's too good. He's a
1/1
for 1 with a neat ability, pretty damn good in
limited.
Contructed:2
Limited:3.5 |
