Shield Wing ...
 
Er ... I don't get it. Up to twice per turn, if this monster would be destroyed by battle, it is not destroyed ... Fine. That's an OK wall ...
there are better monsters that do the exact same thing but can't be destroyed at ALL by battle ... so why THIS? ... It's wind ... ok, so what? ... It's 2 stars ... again - who cares? ... and it's got no ATK. ... So basically its just short of crap. It's a Winged Beast, so it can fit in with Blackwings, but then again it's a Wind monster, not Dark, so ... yeah. Not really ...
 
He's not "nothing" ... but he may as well be.
 
Traditional: 1/5
Advanced: 1.5/5
 
- FREEZA

Shield Wing:

I don't see much use for this card outside of maybe a Dark Simorgh deck, or if you really need a card to fill up space in a stall deck. True, it makes a nice wall without the draw back of Spirit Reaper's target effect, but I see a lot of monster removal being prominent in this format... so if your opponent wants to get rid of this guy, they most likely will be able to. Perhaps I've looked over some combo or deck that successfully utilizes this card, but until I find something more substantial to do with him, this little dude goes to the "worthless" pile.

Traditional: 1.0
Advanced: 1.5