Pojo's Magic The Gathering news, tips, strategies and more!

Pojo's MTG
MTG Home
Message Board
News & Archives
Deck Garage
BMoor Dolf BeJoSe

Columnists
Paul's Perspective
Jeff Zandi
DeQuan Watson
Jordon Kronick
IQ
Aburame Shino
Rare Hunter
Tim Stoltzfus
WiCkEd
Judge Bill's Corner


Trading Card
Game

Card of the Day
Guide for Newbies
Decks to Beat
Featured Articles
Peasant Magic
Fan Tips
Tourney Reports


Other
Color Chart
Book Reviews
Online Play
MTG Links
Staff



120x90 Ad Space
For Rent!



BMoor's Magic The Gathering Deck Garage
Pandora's Box of Cards
January 22, 2007

Sometimes you have a deck list in mind, and sometimes all you have is a pile of cards with no idea on how to make them work together.  Well, as much as I harp on focused strategy, I understand when sometimes you just don't have the resources to make a polished deck list.  When that happens, you make the best deck you can out of what you have.
Dear Bmoor,
 
I'm a newbie and trying to figure out all these rules and get a grip on the stuff everyone else seems to know already. Could you help me devise a deck that kicks ass without getting too complicated till I learn WTF I'm doing? My deck right now is Black & White, but I think I'm going to change it to Black & Red once I know what I'm doing. Your help would be much appreciated, I'm getting tromped all over in my own house! Thanks in advance for any help you may provide...
 
~Pandora
 
I can buy other cards if you think I should have them. Here's what I have to work with:
 
DEAD / BLACK PLAINS / WHITE ARTIFACTS
PHYREXIAN GARGANTUA ANGELIC BLESSING VOYAGER STAFF
COERCION x2 SACRED NECTAR AZORIUS SIGNET
RAISE DEAD x2 STORY CIRCLE TANGLEBLOOM
DARK BANISHING x2 REVERSE DAMAGE  
FESTERING GOBLIN BLINDING ANGEL  
HOLLOW DOGS x2 BLESSED ORATOR  
HIGHWAY ROBBER GIFT OF ESTATES  
GRAVEDIGGER x2 SERRA'S BLESSING  
FEAR PACIFISM x2  
CONTAMINATED BOND AVEN FLOCK  
UNHOLY STRENGTH HONOR GUARD  
BLACKMAIL CROSSBOW INFANTRY  
ZOMBIFY GLORY SEEKER  
CONSUME SPIRIT FOOT SOLDIER x2  
CRUEL EDICT SUNTAIL HAWK  
DRUDGE SKELETONS STOIC EPHEMERA  
DEATH GAZER x2 SELESNYA GUILDMAGE  
NEKRARAAL x2 THREE DREAMS  
UNDERWORLD DREAMS FIELD MARSHAL   
FOUL IMP x3 KJELDORAN WAR CRY x2  
SERPENT WARRIOR x3 KJELDORAN OUTRIDER  
SCATHE ZOMBIES STEELING STANCE  
SPINELESS THUG MINISTER OF IMPEDIMENTS *B  
GOBHOBBLER RATS SQUALL DRIFTER  
GUARDIAN OF VITU-GHAZI COURIER HAWK  
THOUGT PICKER WITCH VALOR MADE REAL  
LAST GRASP URSINE FYLGJA  
GUTLESS GHOUL AURORA EIDOLON  
SEAL OF DOOM CAROM  
GRIM HARVEST CONDEMN  
DEMONS HORN CONCLAVE PHALANX  
WIT'S END 9 PLAINS LAND  
INFECTIOUS HOST    
DIMIR MACHINATIONS    
RIME TRANSFORMATION    
HERALD OF LESHRAC    
CHILL TO THE BONE    
RIME BOUND DEAD    
MARTYR OF BONES    
MOONLIGHT BARGAIN    
VESPER GHOUL    
26 SWAMP LAND    
 

Well, looking over this...list...it became obvious that this isn't really a deck, it's a list of potential cards.  If you took this to a game, you would almost certainly lose because for one, the mana base is too unbalanced, and for another, you have too many cards here that just aren't worth playing (or even unable to be played, in the case of Gobhobbler Rats).
 
That said, we need to thin this down into a real deck.  My initial idea was to make a mono black deck, since you have so many more Swamps than Plains.  However, looking over, there was still not enough playables, so it looks like a Black/White deck is in order.  We'll start with going over the best playables in each color.
 
Black
Coercion x2
Dark Banishing x2
Festering Goblin
Highway Robber
Gravedigger x2
Zombify
Contaminated Bond
Consume Spirit
Cruel Edict
Nekrataal x2
Underworld Dreams
Foul Imp x3
Serpent Warrior x3
Last Gasp
Seal of Doom
Grim Harvest
Herald of Leshrac
Chill to the Bone
Moonlight Bargain
 
White
Angelic Blessing
Story Circle
Blinding Angel
Blessed Orator
Gift of Estates
Pacifism x2
Crossbow Infantry
Suntail Hawk
Three Dreams
Kjeldoran War Cry x2
Minister of Impediments
Squall Drifter
Courier Hawk
Carom
Condemn
 
Other: Tanglebloom
 
That pretty much covers all the cards in this list that are good in general.  Now, can they work together?  Well, Foul Imp and Serpent Warrior cause you to lose life, while Consume Spirit and Tanglebloom cause you to gain it.  Minister of Impediments and Squall Drifter both do the same thing more or less.  You have Contaminated Bond and two Pacifism, which you can search out with Three Dreams, but I suppose you could add in the Unholy Strength and the Serra's Blessing.  You've got a good number of flying creatures, and good removal in Condemn, Dark Banishing, Seal of Doom, and Pacifism.  And Gravedigger and Grim Harvest can bring creatures back, so you can win by essentially having more creatures overall than your opponent. 
 
Now, there are 44 cards in this list, which leaves room for 16 lands.  That's not quite enough, so it appears we should drop a few cards.  Trust me, in a deck where the cards are all over the map like this, you want to be as close to 60 cards as possible so you don't needlessly reduce your odds of drawing the card you need.  So I guess the bottom layer here would be Serpent Warrior, since it has no way of getting through blockers.  That brings you to 41 spells, and 19 lands, which is respectable for a deck like this that has so many cards that cost two or three mana.  Ideally you'd want 20 or more lands, but what else could come out?  That's up to you, Pandora.
 
From here, my advice is to take this deck as I've outlined it and head back into the fray.  Play some games with it, and try to get a feel for how the deck plays.  Do you have enough mana?  Too much?  Is it the right color mana?  What kinds of strategies are hardest for you to beat?  Is there anything you have no way of dealing with?
 
If you want to get some new cards for this deck, my advice is to first try to get two more Kjeldoran War Cry-- they're just better when you have four in your deck, and not hard to get.  And even at two, they're quite good.  After that, try to buy Guildpact cards-- booster packs if that's what you usually get, but anything Guildpact will do.  You see, Guildpact is the set where Orzhov cards come from, and Orzhov cards are black and white, and most are quite good.  A few boosters of Guildpact shouldn't fail to give you at least a few choice picks for a black/white deck.
Until then, best of luck to you, Pandora, and may the art of the game teach you for yourself what the good cards are and how to best build your deck.
 
~BMoor


 

Copyright© 1998-2007 pojo.com
This site is not sponsored, endorsed, or otherwise affiliated with any of the companies or products featured on this site. This is not an Official Site.