I just wanted to check back briefly
with two important points. I read most of the
feedback on my work on the forums; thank you for
your responses and it's what keeps me writing.
However, I just wanted to clarify a few points.
1) The article wasn't intended to disparage Emon in
any way. Like most good friends, I don't like to
backstab people openly in a public forum. Because I
haven't spoken with him since I've come to
Australia, I have no idea about any of the details
in the incident. The basic point was that he was
good enough to be one of the best ever without
cheating, but might have resorted to cheating
anyways like a Barry Bonds.
2) I've received many responses agreeing with me
about the judge comment, but I still felt I should
retract that statement and apologize. The good folks
at Upper Deck Entertainment have done an excellent
job of promoting this game and ironing out the
rulings. Like a lot of you, I remember the dark days
back around Pharaoh's Servant when the judge board
and Netrep hadn't come up yet; it was a nightmare
trying to sort out different concepts like ignition
effects and priority in the phase.
Most of the judges you see at events aren't
receiving compensation for their eight hours of
work, other than product. And most of the judges
that I've talked to from the Southern California
area and certainly all of the professional stud
muffin leaders at the forefront such as Julia
Hedberg, Curtis Schultz, and others show nothing but
class and dignity in the face of sweaty players.
The few bad apples that seek judgehood to reverse
their failing confidence and lack of success as
players shouldn't reflect badly upon the entire
community. I am sorry. Scratch that statement from
my record! |